Mastro's City Hall

Reviews about Mastro's City Hall

• 3 / 5

  By Nancy Sexton
  Most of the food was great but not worth the price. We dined at Steak 44 the night before and it was MUCH better (and the same price). I made reservations for a party of 4 and was told we would be in the lounge area. As we wanted to watch a game that night, this was not an issue. However, upon arriving, we were seated at a VERY small high-top table that was really only meant for 2 people. There was no way to fit 4 plates, 4 drinks and the sides on the table at the same time. And, because of where we were seated, we had groups of people congregating around us as we were eating. For $150/person, I don't like someone breathing over my neck while I dine! And, I ordered the 8 oz filet cooked medium. When I cut into it, it was well done and extremely dry. I did send it back after the waitress and manager both agreed it was well overcooked (I never send food back but for the price, it just wasn't edible). The next steak was cooked perfectly but because I had to wait another 15 minutes for it, I had already filled up on the side dishes. They did give us a free dessert (that was delicious) but for a $50 steak, it should have been perfect the first time. Being seated in the lounge, it was very loud as others have commented on as well. That did not seem to be the case in the dining room but even at a tiny bar top table, we could barely hear one another. Most of our food was delicious but I agree there are far better options for the same price in Scottsdale.
  November 03, 2016
• 5 / 5

  By Nathan Reyes
  The food is excellent! The service is fantastic. The staff go above and beyond to make you feel welcome and important. Loved it!
  October 08, 2016
• 5 / 5

  By Sean Gordon
  Great apps. Unreal steak. Sides were delish. This place has a live band too. Awesome vibes. Perfect for a party of 19 - great host and servers! Would definitely go back
  August 31, 2016